Nika Shakarami, killed on September 20, 2022 by Iranian security forces during “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests
UPDATE, MAY 7:
Political prisoner Shirin Saeedi has been sentenced to five years in prison by a Revolutionary Court in Tehran.
Saeedi was arrested last December 23 and taken to Tehran’s Evin Prison. She was convicted of “assembly and collusion to act against national security”.
Mahmud Mehrabi, arrested in February 2023, has been sentenced to death by a court in Isfahan in central Iran.
Mehrabi was detained over posts on social media critical of the Iranian regime. He was convicted of “corruption on Earth”.
Mehrabi’s lawyer Babak Farsani indicated that he will appeal “serious problems” with the verdict.
UPDATE 0925 GMT:
Journalist and activist Dina Ghalibaf has been released on bail after almost two weeks of detention.
Ghalibaf was detained on April 16. A day earlier, she posted on social media about sexual assault and electric shocks by Iran’s morality police when they seized her at a Tehran metro station over “improper hijab”.
See also Iran Updates: Sexually Assaulted in Detention, Journalist Ghalibaf is Re-Arrested
UPDATE, MAY 2:
The Center for Human Rights in Iran has called for the release from prison of cartoonist and civil rights activist Atena Farghadani, claiming she has been tortured.
Farghadani was seized on April 13 by Revolutionary Guards intelligence operatives. She was trying to display one of her cartoons outside the Supreme Leader’s compound in Tehran.
“After being transported to a safe house, she endured brutal torture, resulting in loss of consciousness from heavy bleeding and head injuries,” said human rights lawyer Mohammad Moghimi. “Several hours later, she regained consciousness in the prayer room of the security police.”
The lawyer said Farghadani was initially transferred to Qarchak Prison, south of Tehran, but “officials there refused to accept her due to signs of torture on her face and body”. She was then taken to Tehran’s Evin Prison.
The activist faces charges of “insulting the sacred”, “propaganda against the state,” and “disrupting public order,” with up to seven years in prison if she is convicted.
CHRI Executive Director Hadi Ghaemi explains:
Farghadani is an artist, an activist, and a woman, all of which make Islamic Republic officials tremble.
She had a target on her back for resolutely standing up to the Islamic Republic’s repression. The international community should demand her immediate release.
Her commitment to freedom and justice is unwavering and calls for her freedom by fellow cartoonists and artists should be amplified by all defenders of human rights.
UPDATE, MAY 1:
Islamic scholar and rights activist Sedigheh Vasmaghi has been bailed from prison amid concerns over her deteriorating health.
Vasmaghi, moved to hospital from Tehran’s Evin Prison last month, was released on Monday.
A critic of compulsory hijab, Vasmaghi posted a video on social media in November where her head was uncovered. She was seized at her home on March 16, charged with “propaganda against the system in cyberspace” and “public appearances without Shari’a-compliant hijab”.
Authorities refused several times to accept the urgent requests of doctors that Vasmaghi be moved to hospital, but relented as she went blind.
In a letter to a UN fact-finding committee, the scholar described her wrongful arrest and the brutal treatment and torture at the hands of regime officials. Despite her blindness, she was repeatedly taken for interrogation without legal representation.
See also Iran Updates: 11 Women’s Rights Activists Given 1 to 6+ Years in Prison
ORIGINAL ENTRY, APRIL 30: A leaked document from Iran’s Revolutionary Guards confirms that 16-year-old Nika Shakarami (pictured), a participant in the “Woman, Life, Freedom” protests, was sexually assaulted and killed by three members of Iranian security forces.
Shakarami, 16, disappeared from a demonstration on September 20, 2022, four days after the protests began over the death of Mahsa Amini — detained and reportedly beaten by “morality police” over “inappropriate attire” — in police custody. Her family found her body in a mortuary nine days later.
The Iranian regime denied any connection between Shahkarami, the mass demonstration, and security forces — even though video showed her in the gathering near Laleh Park in central Tehran, standing on a dumpster setting fire to hijabs as others chants “Death to the Dictator” about the Supreme Leader. Authorities claimed she killed herself by jumping off a roof, but wounds on her body indicated she had been assaulted.
Confirmation of A Killing
Claims about a leaked report first circulated in February. The BBC checked details with multiple sources to corroborate the statements in the document.
The “Highly Confidential” memorandum summarizes a hearing of the Revolutionary Guards on the case. It includes the names of the killers, from the paramilitary group Iranian Hezbollah, and the senior Guards commanders who covered up the murder.
Hezbollah’s Team 12 was one of several undercover security units monitoring the demonstration in Laleh Park. It suspected Shahkarami “of leadership, due to her unconventional behavior and repeated calls with her mobile phone”.
One of the team, posing as a protester, went into the crowd to confirm the teen’s role and called in colleagues to arrest her. She fled, calling a friend to say she was being chased by security forces.
Almost an hour later, she was detained and put in Team 12’s unmarked freezer van. It went to a temporary police camp but was turned away from the overcrowded facility. The commander of a detention center refused to admit Shakarami because she “was constantly swearing and chanting”.
As the van headed for Tehran’s Evin Prison, one member of the security forces sexually assaulted Shakarami as he sat on her. Despite being handcuffed and restrained, she fought back, kicking and swearing. That provoked the officers to beat her with batons.
The team leader, Morteza Jalil, hearing the commotion in the rear of the van, ordered the driver to pull over. He opened the rear door and saw Shakarami’s lifeless body. He cleaned the blood from her face and head, “which were not in a good condition”.
The report confirms that “three batons and three Tasers were all used” in the beating of Shakarami: “It is not clear which one of the blows was the fatal one.”
Jalil said he did not attempt to find out what had happened: “I was only thinking about how to transfer her and didn’t ask any questions of anyone. I only asked: ‘Is she breathing?’.”
Jalil spoke by phone with a senior Guards officer, Capt. Mohammad Zamani, who told him to “dump her on the street”. Shakarami’s body was left in a quiet street under Tehran’s Yadegar-e-Emam highway.
There is no record that any action was taken against the killers, with the report summarizing, “Since the above persons belonged to the forces of Hezbollah, following up this case beyond obtaining the necessary commitments and security guarantees has not been possible.”
The Guards’ Capt. Zamani was given a written reprimand.
High turnout reported in second round of Majlis elections: https://farsnews.ir/Masih/1715351556144037616
Iranian Doctor Arrested for Protesting Execution of Political Prisoners
https://iranwire.com/en/society/128915-iranian-doctor-arrested-for-protesting-execution-of-political-prisoners/
Prisoners Continue Their Hunger Strike on the 15th Week of “No to Execution” Campaign
https://iranwire.com/en/society/128873-prisoners-continue-their-hunger-strike-on-the-15th-week-of-no-to-execution-campaign/
No Veil, No Sale: Iran Links Pharmacies’ Drug Quotas To Hijab Compliance
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-hijab-drugs-pharmacies-fine/32936666.html
The mullah regime is oozing with desperation….
Iranian Police Chief Claims ‘Homeland and Religion Would Vanish Without Hijab’
https://iranwire.com/en/news/128808-iranian-police-chief-claims-homeland-and-religion-would-vanish-without-hijab/
“During the government’s crackdown on women opposing the mandatory hijab, Ahmad Reza Radan remarked, “If they remove the hijab, the homeland and religion will automatically vanish.”
That’s gold!
Iranian Activist Sentenced To Death For Social Media Posts
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-mehrabi-protester-death-sentence/32934964.html
Iran Executed 63 Prisoners in Just Two Weeks
https://iranwire.com/en/news/128554-iran-executed-63-prisoners-in-just-two-weeks/
Struggle for Life: Torture, Uncertainty, and Execution Fate of 7 Kurdish Citizens
https://iranwire.com/en/prisoners/128567-struggle-for-life-torture-uncertainty-and-execution-fate-of-7-kurdish-citizens/
[Editor’s Note: The latest line from Iranian officials, via the semi-official outlet Tasnim….]
New evidence of Nika Shakrami’s death has been published: https://www.tasnimnews.com/fa/news/1403/02/13/3078961
Authorities have released blurred out images of Nika’s dead body and her belongings. Papers relating to judicial and police investigations about her death have also been published.
Trucker Protests Over Fuel Cuts Feed Labor Unrest Sweeping Iran
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-truckers-protest-labor-unrest/32929129.html
Iran files charges over BBC report: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/bbc-ap-iran-mahsa-amini-jerusalem-b2537887.html
“Iranian prosecutors have filed criminal charges against activists and journalists following a BBC report that alleged security forces “sexually assaulted and killed” a 16-year-old girl during the protests over the death of Mahsa Amini.”
[Editor’s Note: A repetition of commenter’s assertion — Point 1 ignores the corroborating statements/evidence in the BBC investigation. Point 2 is incorrect and ignores the BBC explanation of NAJA/FARAJA. Point 3 ignores multiple sources in the investigation. Point 4 is commenter’s ignorance of operations of Iranian security forces and why there are leaks — in most countries, not just Iran.]
1. The BBC has not leaked a report. It has leaked redacted/edited excerpts making it impossible to independently verify.
2. Even the BBC has admitted inconsistencies such as naming Iranian police as “NAJA” when their name changed to “FARAJA” years before.
3. The BBC “confirmed” the report by consulting “a former intelligence officer” who is unnamed and whose credentials are unknown.
4. It beggars belief why such a report would have been written by the IRGC and why, also, it would have been leaked.
[Editor’s Note: The Iranian regime repeats its “official” line about the killing of Nika Shakarami.]
Iranian judiciary refute redacted document about Nika Shakarami’s death and reiterates the information about her suicide: https://www.mizanonline.ir/fa/news/4770855
“On the 30th of Shahrivar 1401 (20 September), it was reported to the police that the body of a teenage girl was found in the backyard of a house on Labafinejad street in Tehran. According to reports, this girl died after falling from the roof and her backpack and mobile phone were on the roof platform of the adjacent four-story house.In the course of investigations at the Tehran Criminal Prosecutor’s Office, a CCTV video from 7 hours before Nika’s body was found was released, which shows her talking on a mobile phone while going to a half-finished house near the back alley of her aunt’s house. The next morning, her body was found in the yard overlooking the balcony of the unfinished house.”
https://www.hamshahrionline.ir/news/848443
“These documents have no date, no attachment, and no letter number. It is not even clear which person or organization is the recipient and the sender. The BBC’s claims have never had any witnesses or video and audio, and have been satisfied with only a few baseless letters. The BBC has not even taken care to change the name of the police command in the head of this letter to Faraja. Since 1400, the command of the police force has changed its name from Naja to Faraja.”
[Editor’s Note: Another weak attempt at rebuttal by pro-Iran regime activists — as BBC Persian makes clear, “The BBC has redacted the documents to protect the safety of those who provided them.”]
Another social media user asks why the BBC’s “redacted version” has included the look of a paper document: https://twitter.com/Partokiya/status/1785316449591898276
“If these documents are redacted, what was the need to give a printed paper effect? If you reconstructed the printing effect, why didn’t you reconstruct the font and seals?
The BBC has admitted not releasing the “original documents”: https://twitter.com/bbcpersian/status/1785283794594840768
[Editor’s Note: The Iranian regime’s response, through State media, to the BBC investigation establishes its concern about the significance of Shakarami’s killing.
Note that the Tehran Times ignores the BBC’s corroboration of the document, specifically explaining why it was important to establish that it was not a forgery, and that it misrepresents the comments made by Shakarami’s mother.]
BBC’s sensationalising media campaign against Iran: https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/497895/BBC-s-sensational-media-campaign-against-Iran
“The letter lacks essential hallmarks of authenticity. Notably absent are common features found in official correspondence, such as standardized fonts and seals indicating high confidentiality. Additionally, the letter fails to include crucial temporal markers, a glaring oversight that further undermines its legitimacy. Furthermore, linguistic anomalies within the letter raise red flags, notably the use of terminology inconsistent with Iran’s judicial proceedings…..While the BBC report claimed the body was found close to 10 p.m., statements from Nika Shakarami’s mother contradicted this assertion, indicating a conversation with Nika at the same time.”
[Editor’s Note: A case of diversion — the commenter offers no specific information about this Revolutionary Guards document and its corroboration by the multiple sources in the BBC’s investigation.]
This would not be the first time the Iranian opposition has produced such forged documents. In 2009, a “leaked memo” allegedly written by the Interior Minister to Khamenei claimed that Ahmadinejad had won only 5.7 million votes coming in third place in the presidential election that year: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/middleeast/iran/5540211/Iran-protest-cancelled-as-leaked-election-results-show-Mahmoud-Amadinejad-came-third.html
The fake memo, which looks authentic, can be seen here: https://www.flickr.com/photos/andishehnouraee/3635977616
[Editor’s Note: There is no inconsistency between protection of sources and the naming of the suspects in the killing of Nika Shakarami.]
Except that no that has been produced/released, just some passages with a letterhead purportedly from the Revolutionary Guards. The BBC has not identified the sources for its corroboration/confirmation except what they claim is an unnamed former intelligence officer. Had they produced audio or visual evidence, this would have been a revelation, but not this. The BBC also claims it wants to protect its sources but then names the allleged perpetrators of the violence against Shakarami.
“…The BBC also claims it wants to protect its sources but then names the allleged perpetrators of the violence against Shakarami.”
You must have been dropped on your head when you were a baby…
In the islamic state people lives means very little, and the bottom is where women belong. Aside from that, only “agha” (SL) and his loyal flock matter, and only as long as the flock tow his line closely. That is shown day in day out in regime behavior.
Iran: Samira Akbari’s Death Highlights Disturbing Trend
https://iranwire.com/en/women/128371-rising-femicide-in-iran-samira-akbaris-death-highlights-disturbing-trend/