A woman stands on a car and salutes the crowd gathering for the 40th day ceremony for Mahsa Amini, who died in Iranian police custody on September 16, 2022
Originally published by The Guardian:
UPDATE, MARCH 28:
The UN Special Rapporteur for Human Rights in Iran, Javaid Rehman, follows up the report of a UN fact-finding mission with an appeal to the Iranian leadership.
UN Special Rapporteur @JavaidRehman calls on Iranian authorities to abolish death penalty & end gender apartheid. The expert presents key findings from his latest report on the situation of human rights in #Iran at #HRC55.https://t.co/0fayeBNYoh pic.twitter.com/yZMMSur49d
— UN Special Procedures (@UN_SPExperts) March 27, 2024
UPDATE, MARCH 19:
A UN fact-finding mission has found Iranian authorities responsible for the death of Mahsa Amini in September 2022.
Amini, 22, was seized and reportedly beaten by “morality police” when she was stopped in Tehran for “inappropriate attire”. She collapsed in a police detention center, fell into a coma, and passed away three days later.
Her death sparked the nationwide “Woman, Life, Freedom” challenging compulsory hijab and seeking rights, reforms, and justice.
Sara Hossain, the chairperson of the fact-finding mission, told the UN Human Rights Council on Monday, “Our investigation established that her death was unlawful and caused by physical violence in the custody of state authorities.”
Summarizing the mission’s reports, she said the protests were met by “egregious human rights violations”, including extra-judicial executions, arbitrary arrests, torture, rape and sexual violence, and ill treatment.
<"These acts were conducted in the context of a widespread and systematic attack against women and girls, and other persons expressing support for human rights," she emphasized.
See also Iran’s Security Forces Raped and Tortured Women’s Rights Protesters — Amnesty
“Some of these serious violations of human rights thus rose to the level of crimes against humanity,” Hossain noted, with women and girls in Iran confronted daily by discrimination “affecting virtually all aspects of their private and public lives”.
It is hard to fathom that in the 21st century, women’s access to the most basic service and opportunities, such as schools, universities, hospitals, and courts, or to opportunities for employment in government or other sectors, should be subjected to a wholly arbitrary requirement of wearing the mandatory hijab.
The @UN Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on the Islamic Republic of #Iran concluded that Jina #MahsaAmini's death was unlawful and that the State was responsible.
A year-and-a-half after her death, Iranian women continue to suffer, the #IranFFM said.#HRC55 pic.twitter.com/iedIBPIAmk
— United Nations Human Rights Council | #HRC55 (@UN_HRC) March 18, 2024
The UN’s Special Rapporteur on Human Rights in Iran, Javaid Rehman, echoed the concerns about abuse and deprivation of rights, speaking of the “deeply concerning” impunity of authorities.
He noted Iran’s spiralling rate of executions, with hangings up 43% in 2023 to reach more than 800. He underlined that many of the executions follow trials that do not meet fair standards, especially those related to the Woman, Life, Freedom protests.
Iran’s representative Kazem Gharibabadi insisted that the Mission “lacked the minimum level of independence and impartiality”. He made no reference to the deaths, injuries, and deaths of protesters, speaking solely about “law enforcement forces who lost their lives”.
The statements of the Iranian delegation were rebuffed by Mercedeh Shahinkar and Kowsar Eftekhari, victims of violence by security forces.
“Their defense is an insult to us,” Shahinkar said. “We came here to defend human rights. Violations must be criticized regardless of location.”
Eftekhari added, “They prioritize political and economic interests over Iranian citizens’ oppression. They shouldn’t defend a government that commits crimes against humanity.”
ORIGINAL ENTRY, MARCH 8:
The Iranian regime’s human rights violations during its brutal suppression of protests in 2022 amount to crimes against humanity, a UN fact-finding mission has said.
Established by the UN human rights council in November 2022 – two months after the Woman, Life, Freedom protests swept the country in response to the death in custody of Mahsa Amini – the FFM has released a report concluding the regime carried out widespread and sustained human rights violations against its own people, which broke international laws and specifically targeted women and girls.
Read The Full Report
The report also investigated and corroborated accounts published in the Guardian that female protesters had been specifically targeted because of their gender and were shot at close range in the face and genitals – actions the report cites as evidence of crimes committed by the state against the civilian population.
See also Iran’s Security Forces Are Firing at Faces and Genitalia of Female Protesters
The report states: “The mission has…established that many of the serious human rights violations…amount to crimes against humanity – specifically those of murder; imprisonment; torture; rape and other forms of sexual violence; persecution; enforced disappearance and other inhumane acts – that have been committed as part of a widespread and systematic attack directed against a civilian population, namely women, girls and others expressing support for human rights.”
See also Iran’s Security Forces Raped and Tortured Women’s Rights Protesters — Amnesty
According to Human Rights Watch, more than 500 people, including 68 children, were killed by security forces during the protests. It is estimated that more than 20,000 protesters were arrested.
The FFM team concluded that throughout the protests, the Iranian government “committed a series of extensive, sustained and continuing acts that individually constitute human rights violations directed against women, girls and persons expressing support for gender equality and the rights of women and girls and, cumulatively, constitute what the mission assesses to be gender persecution in the context of the protests and associated repr
ession of fundamental rights”.
The report said it had found that some of those arrested and detained by the authorities were subject to beatings and rape, electrocution, forced nudity and sexual assault, including on children.
It also found that LGBTQ+ people arrested during the protests had been subjected to violence and human rights violations. Iranian public officials were also found to have intentionally inflicted acts of torture to attain forced confessions from detainees.
The UN report called upon the Iranian authorities to “provide justice, truth and reparations to victims of human rights violations in connection with the protests that started on 16 September 2022, survivors and their families, in accordance with international human rights standards”.
“These acts form part of a widespread and systematic attack directed against the civilian population in Iran, namely against women, girls, boys and men who have demanded freedom, equality, dignity and accountability,” said Sara Hossain, chair of the FFM. “We urge the government to immediately halt the repression of those who have engaged in peaceful protests, in particular women and girls.”
The team is expected to present its findings, conclusions and recommendations in a detailed 400-page report to the UN in Geneva at the end of March.
The release of the report comes as the Iranian government continues to target the families of protesters and those killed during the demonstrations as well as journalists (in Iran and abroad), human rights activists, lawyers and doctors, say human rights groups.
According to Amnesty International’s latest report released this week, Iranian authorities have launched a draconian campaign to enforce the compulsory hijab laws on women and girls.
Diana Eltahawy, Amnesty International’s deputy director for the Middle East and north Africa, said: “Iran’s authorities are terrorising women and girls by subjecting them to constant surveillance and policing, disrupting their daily lives and causing them immense mental distress. Their draconian tactics span from stopping female drivers on the road … to imposing inhumane flogging and prison sentences.”
Iranian Journalist Stabbed in London
https://iranwire.com/en/news/126799-iranian-journalist-stabbed-in-london/
Children As Young As 16 In Iran Sell Kidneys Amid Poverty
https://www.iranintl.com/en/202403289088
Activists Hail Senate Move To Advance Iran Sanctions Bill
https://www.iranintl.com/en/202403296495
Iranian Women’s Rights Activists Sentenced To Long Prison Terms
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-women-activists-sentenced-long-prison-terms/32881067.html
Killings, Blindings and Discrimination: UN Mission Accuses Iranian Govt of Crimes Against Humanity
https://iranwire.com/en/features/126744-killings-blindings-and-discrimination-un-mission-accuses-iranian-govt-of-crimes-against-humanity/
Senior Iranian Cleric Accused Of Corruption In Land Deal
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-imam-seddiqi-corruption-lan-deal/32868521.html
[Editor’s Note: The Iran regime’s denial that it had anything to do with the reported beating, hospitalization, and death of Mahsa Amini]
Fact-finding committee explains the truth about the death of Mahsa Amini: https://www.tabnak.ir/fa/news/1227563
“In the report of the Committee of Councils of the Islamic Council on the death of Mrs. Mahsa Amini, which was presented in a public meeting on Sunday 24 Mehr 1401, it was emphasized that “according to the contents of the case, the written announcements of the relevant agencies, the explanations of the relevant authorities, the review of the full footage of the police CCTV cameras Public security, minutes of local examination meetings and field investigations of the special inspection of Greater Tehran Police Command, statements of those present at the scene and hall of the Public Security Police Training Department, a number of citizens, businesses and drivers of passenger cars stationed at the site, review of documents and consideration of documents, none There was no assault and physical attack during the confrontation, transfer and placement of the late Mrs. Amini at the public security police station. According to the country’s forensic medical report (based on hospital records, physical examination, autopsy, sampling, and specialized tests), it states that the death of the named person was not due to physical contact, beating, or any kind “
[Editor’s Note: Rather than holding the personnel who reportedly beat Mahsa Amini accountable, the regime covered up the incident. Rather than acknowledge any responsibility for the compulsory hijab law that led to her detention and death, the regime doubled down on that law. Rather than listen to the issues raised by protesters, the regime’s security forces arrested, injured, and killed them.
So, yes, the regime is responsible.]
Even if Mahsa Amini were beaten by the police, the “regime” was clearly not responsible for her death any more than the U.S Government was responsible for the actions of Derek Chauvin in the death of George Floyd. Hijab enforcement does not given a license to the police to use excessive physical force such as striking a person’s head with a baton – as claimed – which would be assault/battery.
[Editor’s Note: After more than a year, the regime finally produces a report about the protesters whom its security forces killed.
It should be noted that the actual number of dead is likely to be far higher than the 300 — the commenter misrepresents the figures provided by the human rights organizer HRANA, which reports at least 522 protesters slain.]
Iran Says Fewer Than 300 Died In 2022 Mahsa Amini Protests: https://www.barrons.com/news/iran-says-fewer-than-300-died-in-2022-mahsa-amini-protests-9e683b21
“Published on Sunday, the special report from the office of the president estimated that 281 people died in the months of unrest that followed Amini’s death in September 2022. The detailed document, almost 300 pages long, was published nine days after a report commissioned by the United Nations Human Rights Council which accused Iran of crimes against humanity.”
The figure of 281 comports with a*** verified*** figure of 271 by HRANA (https://www.en-hrana.org/tag/iran-protests-2022/) and is not too dissimilar to a list of 330 provided by Iranwire: https://iranwire.com/en/politics/108299-remembering-victims-iran-protests-2022/
The Iranian authorities have claimed that some who died claimed to have been killed during protests did so because of sickness, suicide and unrelated accidents. They also maintain that many of the deaths were caused by armed groups firing at police and bystanders.
You murderers, you didn’t just kill over 500 people in the streets, you also raped several protesters in back allies, then threw their bodies of roof tops claiming they had committed suicide. That wasn’t enough you also injured and blinded several hundreds of people by deliberately shooting at their faces…
Hundreds of Protesters in Iran Blinded by Metal Pellets and Rubber Bullets
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/19/world/asia/iran-protesters-eye-injuries.html
Holy Land Grab! Khamenei’s Man Embroiled In Corruption
https://www.iranintl.com/en/202403171106
[Editor’s Note: The Iran regime’s response to the UN report on its human rights abuses….]
Selective Human Rights in FFM report on Iran: https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/496178/Selective-Human-Rights
Iranian Protesters Voice Outrage During Fire Festival
https://www.rferl.org/a/iran-tehran-rasht-protest-fire-festival-chant-freedom-chaharshanbe-suri-norouz-new-year/32860381.html
[Editor’s Note: Iran’s oil production is still below the level of 2018 — and, of course, production does not necessarily equate to exports, which are the target of sanctions.]
EIA estimates Iran’s crude and condensate production at 3.6 million barrels per day: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=61545
That would mean that sanctions against Iran have, in essence, failed. It seems crude production is 3.2 mbpd and condensate is 0.4 mbd: https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/496143/Iran-s-oil-output-reaches-3-2m-bpd-in-February-EIA
Finally, a sensible article by Simon Tisdall of the Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2024/mar/12/global-outlook-perilous-labour-trident-aid-iran
“Unlike the US, Britain maintains full diplomatic relations with Iran and can draw on long-established institutional knowledge of the country. Labour should use this traditional engagement to restart the dialogue with Iran’s leadership that was fatally undermined by Trump. Improved western relations with Tehran, arguably the leading regional power, are the key to a safer, less volatile Middle East – and to reducing Islamophobic and antisemitic spillovers in Britain. Iraq, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen are all countries where Iran wields significant influence. Less confrontational policies and careful diplomacy could deliver more productive relationships. Resuming talks on limiting Iran’s nuclear arms-related capabilities in return for lifting sanctions would be a confidence-building start. Yet Labour’s larger aim should be to enlist Iran’s help in resolving the Israel-Gaza conflict and turning dreams of an independent, sovereign Palestinian state into reality.”
Shocked!!! Bullshiters like bullshiters
Imprisoned Iranian Cleric Says Under Pressure To Confess To Crimes He Didn’t Commit
https://www.rferl.org/a/imprisoned-iran-cleric-pressure-confess/32855798.html
[Editor’s Note: The commenter’s assertion that “no journalists have doubted the turnout” is untrue. But some of those who have raise this have been questioned and threatened with punishment, including detention.]
https://www.voanews.com/a/flashpoint-iran-how-iran-settled-on-41-election-turnout-figure-that-opposition-activists-say-is-inflated-/7515553.html
“How Iran Settled on 41% Election Turnout Figure That Opposition Activists Say is Inflated”
Inside Iran, no journalists have doubted the turnout and official results. Neither have virtually all of the candidates themselves.
Gallup poll finds the following: https://news.gallup.com/poll/611210/iran-votes-lukewarm-leadership-cool-economy.aspx
1. 61% of Iranians are struggling to make ends meet
2. 52% disapprove of their government’s performance.
3. 43% of young Iranians want to leave the country.
4. 10% of Iranians support the US Government.
In a First, UN Report Implicates Ali Khamenei in Crimes Against Humanity
https://iranwire.com/en/politics/126281-in-a-first-un-report-implicates-ali-khamenei-in-crimes-against-humanity/
[Editor’s Note: Commenter tries to bury the widespread reports of an inflated turnout figure and of a large protest vote spoiling ballots by citing the official returns — which of course are put out by the authorities who would be inflating turnout and playing down the protest vote.]
Turnout by province in election: https://www.mehrnews.com/photo/6045948
The turnout varied from 64% to just 26%. Interestingly, Kurdistan had a turnout of 30% which is about average for the province. West Azerbaijan – home to many Kurds and which witnessed violent clashes in cities like Mahabad, Oshnaviyeh and Boukan – had a higher turnout than the national average.
And for those denying the official turnout, the results for all 3,372 candidates standing in Tehran can be counted: https://www.asriran.com/fa/news/949097/3372
Just need to count the votes and they come to 1.569 million. The 0.35 million invalid votes are not included. Reformist candidates like Alireza Khamisian, Ahmad Mazani and Mohsen Alijani Zamani did especially badly. They were not on the “Voice of the Naton” list.
Of the 245 seats decided, the Coalition Council has won 90 seats, other principlists 77, independents 49, reformists 24 and religious minorities 5
https://www.tasnimnews.com/fa/news/1402/12/12/3048081
Reformist candidates did well in some of the small ethnic minority provinces. They did not fare well in Kerman where they had top candidates in all constituencies.
Stasis consulting, which did phone polling before the election, found that 44% of the respondents stated that they were “very likely” to vote
https://surveycenter.io/projectfuture/iran2024electionturnoutislow/en/?active-question=10
Hardliner Disobedience Signals Weakness In Iran’s Khamenei
https://www.iranintl.com/en/202403091171
Even his own stray thugs are not listening…
Stasis consulting poll reveals mixed views on Raisi: https://surveycenter.io/projectfuture/iran2024electionturnoutislow/en/
The telephone poll indicated that 44% of voters (Q10) were “very likely” to vote, close to the 41% official turnout. It indicated that Raisi has a 32% approval rating (Q16) but is also the most popular politician out of a list of 5 that includes Khatami, Rouhani, Ahmadinejad and Qalibaf (Q15). He would also beat Zarif in next year’s presidential election (Q25).
Rouhani received support from just 4%.
[Editor’s Note: Iran’s State media lashes out at former President Mohammad Khatami because he did not support the managed elections earlier this month.]
Criticism of Khatami grows in Iran: https://www.isna.ir/news/1402121812742
Khatami is accused of turning away from elections whilst having backed Rouhani as the currency collapsed during the latter’s presidency, and Iran suffered violent protests over the hike in fuel prices. He is also accused of admitting in private that there was no fraud in the 2009 presidential election but in public is deliberately ambiguous and evasive.
Putting a number in front of your routine bullshit posts doesn’t make not to be bullshit