Chancellor Rishi Sunak announces UK Government measures to assist self-employed during Coronavirus crisis, March 26, 2020
Originally published by the Birmingham Business School Blog:
In 1940, John Maynard Keynes famously published the book How to Pay for the War, which proposed re-assigning UK industrial production to support the World War II effort and deferring workers’ pay by issuing credits that would be redeemed after the conflict.
The aim of these measures was to reduce the consumption of “butter” during the war to make way for production of “guns” and to disburse credits later to rekindle economic growth. The plan was in part enacted, though the post-war disbursement of credits was much slower than Keynes had recommended. The National Savings Movement was mobilized during the war to raise funds to help “Save Your Way to Victory’.
EA on talkRADIO: Can UK Government Be Trusted Over Coronavirus? To fund World War I, the government came off the gold standard. The Treasury issued a sizable tranche of bank notes, not backed by gold, that was essentially a non-interest bearing loan. The government also took out a large loan in 1914, for which the Bank of England was the leading subscriber, paying 3.5% interest to be redeemed at par in 1925-28. Subsequent rounds of funding for the war were short-term, involving Treasury and Exchequer bonds of up to 12 months.
The War on COVID-19
The government’s aim during the war on COVID-19 is to prop up consumption by paying 80% of wages, and supporting lending to businesses through guaranteed loan schemes, grants, and other funding via Bank of England corporate asset purchases. Extra support is being provided to the National Health Service and local councils responsible for social care.
To fund these initiatives, the Treasury has taken out a large interest-free loan from the Bank of England, the term of which is seemingly indeterminate.
The background to this is Government fiscal initiatives to prevent an economic depression after the 1997-9 financial crisis, after a period of increased expenditure on measures to reduce child and pensioner poverty and on the NHS.
The post-crisis period was marked by a decade of austerity, during which the government attempted to reduce the deficit as far as possible without increasing taxes. It tried to reduce the debt burden, primarily through economic growth, but this was disappointing due to a lack of productivity increases.
After the Crisis
Is another, perhaps sharper, period of austerity to be expected, ahead of a push to achieve “net-zero” carbon emissions by 2050 in order to avert a global warming induced calamity?
Modern Monetary Theory, as championed by Stephanie Kelton, proposes that austerity will be unnecessary since the Treasury need never repay the Bank of England’s loan to the government. The Bank can simply hold onto the corporate and government assets it purchases until maturity.
The government need only issue COVID-19 Bonds, or raise taxes, if significant inflation eventually results in a post-crisis period.
Do you think that the EU Corona bonds might still come about as a means to cancel out the (EU) debt ? In extremis the EU could be largely self sufficient only importing some raw materials and having the means to export to any market still functioning.. an internal EU barter arrangement could not only bring closer political alignment but also to build pressure to block UK financial services access to the EU. Time for a Brexit rethink ?
Rob,
I think the EU bonds are viable for Europe but not, unless UK Government backs away from Brexit, for Britain.
S.