Islamic State Analysis: Targeting Refugees is Not the Answer


PHOTO: Syrian refugees asleep on the ground in Serbia

Aaron Zelin writes for The Washington Institute:

In light of Friday’s terrorist attacks in Paris, the question of Syrian refugees fleeing to Europe has come into sharp focus — and been politicized by European and U.S politicians and commentators across the spectrum.

Indeed, this past summer, an exponential increase occurred in the number of individuals making these difficult journeys. The flights were spurred in part by the Assad regime and its allies’ continued assaults on civilian populations and in part by increasing territorial gains by the jihadist groups ISIS [the Islamic State] and Jabhat al-Nusra. Many individuals living in refugee camps thus despaired that they would ever actually return home.

Given that most refugees simply want a safer and better life for their children, and that current media and policy discussions are not considering this issue’s many facets, clarification is essential on misconceptions related to ISIS, refugees, and potential future challenges within Europe in particular.

How ISIS Sees Refugees

For those seeking to blame the Paris attacks on refugees, a look at ISIS’s stance on refugees is instructive. Of particular note is how ISIS could be using these attacks to stoke tensions between European ethnic majorities and the Muslim minorities and newly arrived refugees. Equally important, the migrant flow is anathema to ISIS, undermining the group’s message that its self-styled caliphate is a refuge. If it were a refuge, then hundreds of thousands of people would surely be settling in its lands instead of risking their lives on miserable journeys to Europe. The hostile reaction to refugees, therefore, only bolsters ISIS’s contentions and risks spurring future, avoidable tensions.

ISIS released 12 videos between September 16 and 19, aimed at inserting itself into a discussion highlighted by deaths at sea — especially the crushing image of Alan Kurdi, the child who washed up dead on a Turkish beach. These videos, released by the group’s respective “provinces” in Iraq, Syria, and Yemen, weere aimed both at warning potential refugees of the risks and costs of traveling to Europe and urging them to take refuge in its caliphate.

For example, in its video from Wilayat Salah al-Din (Iraq), ISIS argues that Muslims should leave the infidel’s lands for the lands of Islam, but not vice versa, and that happiness can only be found in the ISIS caliphate. Moreover, in a message from its Wilayat al-Janub (Iraq), ISIS declares that Muslims cannot live or seek refuge in non-Muslim lands and that doing so amounts to apostasy, in effect legitimizing the refugees’ spilt blood. ISIS’s Wilayat al-Furat, on the Syria-Iraq border, militates against migration on the grounds that refugees would be subject to human laws rather than sharia. As a result, according to Wilayat al-Raqqa (Syria), the migrants’ children would abandon Islam — even though Europe’s Muslim population has continued growing in recent decades through various waves of migration.

Another claim holds that Europe is only accepting Muslim refugees as a tactic to increase the Shiite, Druze, and Christian population to defeat ISIS in Syria. Based in northwestern Syria, ISIS’s Wilayat al-Barakah notes further that accepting refugees allegedly forces Muslims to work for Europe’s interests, thereby weakening Islam.

In a video from Wilayat al-Khayr (eastern Syria), ISIS offers advice to those who have already left, stating Muslims should not mix or fraternize with infidels. It suggests that such Muslims will be forced to convert to Christianity in exchange for money or citizenship and that they will be forfeiting their reward in paradise. ISIS’s Wilayat al-Fallujah shows video clips of refugees being beaten by police and claiming that true happiness and dignity can only be had in Muslim countries.

In a message from Wilayat Hadramawt (Yemen), ISIS pushes refugees to actually imagine life once they leave Syria, including exposure to drowning and human smugglers, followed by the injustices and outrages to be experienced in Europe. In a video from Wilayat Homs (Syria), ISIS warns of the threat of conversion and then pivots to describe, by contrast, how ISIS has cared for refugees from the Syrian regime. Wilayat al-Jazirah (on the Syria-Iraq border), for its part, interviews individuals who fled the Kurdish Peshmerga for ISIS territory and boasts of the good life they are now living. Similarly, Wilayat Halab (northern Syria) released a video juxtaposing foreign fighters migrating to ISIS territory with scenes of refugees being mistreated in Europe. Finally, Wilayat Dijlah (Iraq) claims without any proof that many more Syrians are migrating to its caliphate than seeking refuge in places elsewhere internally in Iraq or Syria, in refugee camps, or in Europe.

The Islamic State’s Strategy

Having polarized society in Iraq and Syria, ISIS hopes to do the same in Europe by compelling individuals to take sides and fall back on more tribal, instinctive feelings — or eliminating the “gray zone,” as the group has previously described it. As ISIS and many others are aware, Europe has struggled to integrate many migrant communities in recent decades, leading some second- and third-generation residents to experience an identity crisis. Cognitive openings have followed, which jihadist recruiters have at times filled with a perceived new and stronger identity as well as a more black-and-white worldview. Therefore, an individual who does not feel completely Pakistani or British in Britain, Algerian or French in France, or — possibly in the future — Syrian or German in Germany can now identify solely as a Sunni Muslim.

As a consequence, it is essential to take steps to prevent individuals from giving in to emotional impulses that could further exacerbate Europe’s security dilemma. As this relates to refugees, it is true that ISIS could exploit the crisis to insert operatives into Europe. At the same time, however, one must remember that the group already has thousands of members with European Union passports and has very good document forgers. Therefore, the sole reason for nesting additional operatives in the refugee flows would be to spark a backlash against Syrian and other refugees as well as the native Muslim populations of Europe. Even if this happens, the few jihadist operatives that slip through should not be used to tar the other 99%.

Therefore, the US and Europe should continue to carefully monitor entrants at their borders but also provide the necessary support networks and assistance so that newly arrived refugees feel welcomed and part of their broader society. Without a long-term vision for integrating refugees, and by relying solely on moral imperative, European countries will likely see problems similar to those that have already plagued their migrant policies. Refugees, meanwhile, must understand the ways in which responsibilities and expectations as a resident and future citizen of a liberal democracy differ from those as a subject in an authoritarian society.

None of these steps will be easy, but with mutual respect, understanding, and education, Europe can look forward to a brighter picture in the long run. Needless to say, the refugee-baiters, their rhetoric, and their proposed policies will lead to self-fulfilling ends and make everyone less safe.

Related Posts


  1. This article is by Aaron Zelin.

    It should not be followed by an “About the Author” describing Scott Lucas, unless you change the word “Author” to “Editor”.

  2. According SOHR 50.000 Daesh members are fighting now in Syria – 20,000 of them are from abroad. According to estimates by the European Commission 2.000 of them are from Europe.

    The adolescent of the 2nd generation of migrants in Europe are all caught up in the conflict between the culture of origin (the culture of their parents) and between the success or failure of integration in the country they are living.

    For this 2,000 european Daesh fighters it seems to be that the “Culture of Death
    and Destruction” seems to be an alternative. Unable to affirm life they have chosen to be murderous fighters destroying civilizations and killing everything what`s different.

    From the returnees, we know that a part of them are traumatized completely. –

    At September 2014 the collective of Anonymous on Twitter have announced that it operates a cyberwar campaign called “Operation Ice ISIS” against Deash. The aim of the campaign is to reduce the impact of Daesh on Social Media. Hundreds of user accounts of Daesh have been tracked, adopted and rendered useless in social networks.

    The other problem is much more difficult to solve. It`s the idea of Jihadism which seems to attract many. For sexually frustrated people the story of the 72 virgins after the suicide bombing is seeminly tempting for leaving reality and to dream on in a self created parallel world.

    As long Islam adheres to this “Culture of Death and Destrucion” and if Islam isn`t able to interpret the Koran as a religion to affirm life negating violence this basic problem will persist.

    If brainwashed state sponsert iranian Hizbollah/ basiji/ IRGC – Jihadis are running wild at syria it`s only the other side of the same despicable coin.

    • Thomas van Linge
      Syria: Anonymous (note: Anonymous is the organisation fighting Daesh on socila media) has started providing the Free Syrian Army (FSA) with intel on Daesh members. #OpISIS

      Anonymous has given the FSA data with 200k lines of personal information of members of an underground #Daesh forum.

    • The adolescent of the 2nd generation of migrants in Europe are all caught up in the conflict between the culture of origin (the culture of their parents) and between the success or failure of integration in the country they are living.

      Depends on the parent. Parents who moved to a minority neighborhood and insisted that their kids speak Arabic as their first language, and possibly sent the kid to Koranic classes, and kept on hammering leftwing post-colonial myths into their 12 year old’s head, have a higher chance that their kid engage in terrorism.

      They are brought up to hate western society (of course with the help of leftwing activists), so they basically drop out of society, getting little of an education and less of a work culture. So they become unemployable. Once unemployed and sliding backward, their level of bitterness and anger increases. And of course they blame western society for their own unemployment and poverty.

      Eastern culture: The government is responsible for you, and if you fail, it is because of a corrupt government and racism, as you are the good guy with the good heart. The people in power want to exploit you and the harder you work, the happier they become.
      Western culture: Get off yer damn butt and do something with yer Fing life. Stick that nose to the grindstone, bozo.

      I personally know many Muslim families who integrated into the greater society. Their kids all have self-supporting jobs and are well educated, and have no sympathies or patience for Islam or post-colonialism.

Leave a Comment